[T]he signature Swift humble-brag, modesty that seemed so false it earned its own meme, 'the Taylor Swift Surprised Face'—a reference to the What? Me?! gasps of astonishment she unleashed once too often when her name was called at awards ceremonies.
Still, can you blame her for being shocked? The scale and scope of Swift’s success is startling. In an age of catastrophic music-industry contraction, Swift stands apart; sometimes she has seemed like a one-woman bulwark against the collapse of the traditional record business.
By Jody Rosen, published in Vulture in 2013